Topper Copies

Contrast export-biased growth as against import biased growth with the help of diagrams. Under what conditions could growth be immiserizing?

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Growth in exports or in imports can lead to changes in Terms of Trade which measures relative price index of exports to price index of Imports. This can impact overall welfare of a nation via TOT effect and wealth effect

1. Export biased growth Irrespective of growth happening in home country or foreign country, if cloth (export) biased growth takes place, it leads to deterioration in Terms of Trade for home country (exporting cloth)

[Fig 1: RS and RD, a graph of Pc/PF against relative quantity with the relative supply curve RS and its shifted position RS']

[Fig 2: offer curve, a graph of Import against Export with offer curves C and C' and rays of slope Pc/Pf and Pc/Pf']

Due to export Biased growth, Relative Supply shifts outward to RS' and new relative equilibrium - (Pc/PF)' (Fig 1)

Offer curve of home country shifts from OC to OC' (outward) and causes deterioration in Terms of Trade

Overall effect (Ambiguous) depends on -> 1. wealth (+) effect 2. TOT effect (–)

2. Import biased growth Irrespective of which country is facing growth in food industry, relative commodity prices (Pc/PF) increases and Terms of Trade of home country improves

[Fig 3: a graph of Pc/PF against relative quantity with RD, RS and the shifted supply RS']

[Fig 4: an offer curve graph of Import against Export with curves C and C' and rays Pc/PF' and Pc/PF]

As shown in Fig 3, Q_F & Q_F* ↑ hence RS shifts inward to RS' -> (P_c/P_F) ↑

Fig 4i Offer curve shifts towards axis of import

[overall Impact] -> 1. wealth effect (+) 2. TOT effect (+) - Improvement in overall welfare of home country

Immiserising growth by Jagdish Bhagwati states that a country might get worse off after export oriented growth if negative effect of Terms of Trade decline outweighs positive effects of wealth increase

[a graph of Import (Food) against Export (Cloth) with an outer and an inner production possibility curve, price line Pc/PF = 1 touching the inner curve at A with indifference curve IC, and price line Pc/PF = 1/5 touching the outer curve at B with indifference curve IC'; Fig: Immiserising Growth]

Pc/PF declines to such an extent that SC shifts down to IC1 hence at lower welfare curve.

1. happens rarely but mostly in underdeveloped nations 2. country is large enough to impact world equilibrium prices 3. country is heavily dependent on export - led growth 4. The export of country has low price elasticity in world market

(eg) India's growth in Sugar Industry led to slump in world sugar prices

Resolution for 'Immiserising Growth'

1. Diversification of Export Basket. 2. Balancing Primary commodity exports with Manufactured goods export

(eg) Foreign Trade Policy of India (2023)