"The competitors will match the price reduction more closely than the price increase." Explain the reasons by using the kinked demand curve model. How is the problem of prisoner's dilemma associated with the duopoly model?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Oligopolistic markets exhibit Price Rigidity. Kinked demand curve model by Paul Sweezy is an operational analysis tool which tries to explain the Price stickness/rigidity based on conjectural variation.
Assumptions — 1. Homogeneous Products 2. Small number of large firms
Model: It states that Prices under Oligopoly are sticky due to — 1. Rivals follow price deduction, hence firm donot gain substantial sales - Inelastic demand curve 2. Rivals donot follow Price Increase hence firm faces consumer flight and decline in sales - Elastic demand curve
[a kinked demand curve with Prices on the vertical axis and Quantity on the horizontal, kink K at P₀ and Q₀, an elastic upper section, an inelastic lower section, a discontinuous marginal revenue line and an MC curve; Fig: Kinked demand curve]
As shown in figure, Equilibrium Price = P₀ and Quantity = Q₀ 1. At P > P₀ → firms do not match prices At Q < Q₀ → MR > MC , hence firms will increase output 2. At P < P₀ → Firms match price ( Competition ) At Q > Q₀ → MC > MR, hence firms reduce output
∴ P = P₀ and Q = Q₀ at equilibrium 3. Gap between marginal cost curves depends on difference in elasticities between upper section and lower section 4. As long as marginal cost curve lies in Gap → NO change in Prices 5. usually prices increase when marginal costs rise for all industries (Eg increase in raw material costs)
Criticism :- 1. Not a price determination model & only explains why price remains at kink 2. only holds true during depression period as prices do rise during Boom periods
Problem of Prisoner's Dilemma with Duopoly Model
1. under duopoly model of cournot , both firms donot cooperate and aims for Individual profit maximisation - lose out on Joint profit maximisation and higher gains as seen in Prisoner's dilemma 2. under Bertrand , both firms are naive and set Prices equal marginal cost hence Causing Bertrand Paradox