Compare and contrast Marshallian and Walrasian approaches of the stability in equilibrium.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Market equilibrium entails adjustment process where market demand equals market supply at positive prices
There are 2 approaches to market equilibrium –
| Marshallian | walrasian | |---|---| | i) Partial Equilibrium analysis | i) General equilibrium analysis | | ii) Cetrul paribus as ignores interdependence between price levels of Commodities | ii) Acknowledges the Interdependence among various markets | | iii) Doesnot consider Spill over effect and feedback effect | iii) Considers feedback effect and Spill over effect | | ii) works via Quantity adjustments | iv) works via Price adjustments |
Q_Tea = f(P_Tea, P_coffee) Q_coffee = f(P_coffee, P_Tea)
[a supply and demand graph of price against quantity with equilibrium E and quantities Q₁, Q, Q₂ either side]
At Q₂ : Ps > Pd hence output reduces At Q₁ : Pd > Ps hence output increase
Points to right of equilibrium :- Ps - Pd > 0 Points to left of equilibrium : Ps - Pd < 0
Doesnot lead to Walrasian Stability
[Fig 1: a supply and demand graph with a steep downward demand line and a flatter supply line crossing at P and Q]
[a supply and demand graph with equilibrium E, excess supply (ESG) at the higher price P₂ and excess demand (EDG) at the lower price P₁]
At P₂ :- Qs > Qd hence, Prices will fall At P₁ : Qd > Qs hence, Prices will Increase
Point Below equilibrium → Qs - Qd ≤ 0 Points above equilibrium → Qs - Qd > 0
Doesnot lead to Marshallian Stability
[Fig 2: a supply and demand graph of price against quantity with a downward demand line and a flatter supply line crossing]
As shown in Fig I, Marshallian stable Walrasian stable
As shown in Fig II, Walrasian stable Marshallian unstable
Hence, Walras and Marshal can have unstable or stable, unique or multiple, existent or non-existent equilibrium based on shape of demand and supply curves