Topper Copies

"An economist should know how to distinguish between a policy change which is an improvement and one which makes things worse." In the light of the above statement, outline some important criteria for welfare judgment.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Social welfare entails satisfaction of societal wants. A policy change might lead to improvement in social welfare or make social welfare worse depending on the social welfare function criteria.

1. Paternalistic welfare function / classical (Pigou, Bentham) It tries to maximise sum of individual utilities

U = U1 + U2 + -- + Un

Hence, a policy would improve social welfare if total sum is maximised (utilitarianism / Greatest Good of All) 2. Rawls welfare function: It tries to maximise utility of worst off individual

U = min(Ui)

Hence, a policy would increase social welfare if it makes worst individual Better off 3. Pareto welfare function : It is based on allocative, productive and product mix efficiency. Hence, if a policy increases welfare of an individual without making someone else worse off, then it is counted as improvement. This leads to infinite Pareto optimal solutions at contract curve 4. Kaldor Hicks compensation Principle :

It entails an improvement in social welfare when gainers can compensate losers and still be better off (Kaldor) or losers cannot Bribe gainers to remain at original position (Hicks)

However, it faces from Scitovsky paradox and reduces to Pareto function if actual compensation is alone. 5. Bergson- Samuelson welfare function :-

It incorporates individualistic utilities as monotonic function of Social welfare function. It considers self- evaluation of utilities , considers Interpersonal comparisons to evaluate policy effectiveness . when imposed with Grand utility Production possibility Frontier —> Point of constrained Bliss 6. AK Sen welfare Function : It criticises utility based social welfare evaluation and focuses on expanding freedom of choices

A policy is an improvement if it leads to improvement in capabilities and widens choices (eg National Education Policy 2020)

Hence, Varying criteria of welfare judgement can lead to different results for the same policy prescription Finding the right function poses challenge to economists