Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question (question 4(b)); the answer is written to the question of how a lump-sum tax, a profit tax and a specific sales tax each affect the equilibrium of a monopolist.

Dipti Ranjan Pati, AIR 164, 2024

(i)

The imposition of a lump-sum tax doesn't alter the equilibrium situation of a monopolist as it doesn't affect the marginal cost of production. => A lump-sum tax is similar to the raising of the fixed costs of the producer.

[a price-quantity graph with D and MR, a U-shaped TAC and a higher dotted TAC', and a rising marginal cost curve crossing MR]

=> The monopolist is likely to cease the production only if post-tax, the total average cost (TAC) rises above the demand curve.

(ii)

The effect of a profit tax is again similar to that of a lump sum tax, in so much as it doesn't affect the marginal cost and hence, the equilibrium condition of production.

(iii)

A specific - sales tax, however, alters the variable cost and raises the marginal cost curve to the left.

[a price-quantity graph with two downward-sloping lines, marginal cost curves mc and shifted mc', and quantities q' and q]

→ This raises the price charged and reduces output. → Whether the price rise is equal to, more than & less than the tax, depends on the relative elasticities of supply and demand. → If the relative elasticity of demand to that of supply is higher, then the price rise would be lower than the tax & a part of the tax borne by the producer.