Topper Copies

'A nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility (at constant prices), thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output. However fiscal policy is fully effective in this case' . Do you agree? Explain.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Under fixed exchange rate system with perfect capital mobility, fiscal policy is effective in controlling and influencing output, rather than monetary policy. Ineffectiveness of monetary policy

[an IS-LM diagram with LM₁ and LM₂, interest rates i₁ and i₂ and output Y₁ and Y₂ marked]

In the diagram, with increase in money supply due to expansionary monetary policy, LM curve shifts from LM1 to LM2. Now, because of this interest rate decreases from i1 to i2. This leads to capital outflow. A capital outflow will create decreasing pressure on exchange rate to increase. In order to maintain fixed exchange rate central bank would intervene by selling foreign currency and buying domestic currency. This contracts money supply and LM curve shifts back from LM2 to LM1. Thus, monetary policy is ineffective in influencing output. Effectiveness of fiscal policy

[an IS-LM diagram with IS₁, IS₂, LM₁, LM₂ and equilibrium points 1 to 3]

As shown in the diagram, with expansionary fiscal policy, equilibrium level of interest rate moves from i1 to i2 and IS curve shifts from IS1 to IS2. Now, since, there is an increase in interest rate, so capital inflow is observed in the economy. There will thus, be a pressure on central bank to prevent exchange rate decrease by selling domestic currency and buying foreign currency. Therefore, LM curve shifts from LM1 to LM2. However, while interest rate is restored from i2 to i1, in this process output increases from Y1 to Y2 level. Thus, fiscal policy is effective in increasing output of the economy. Therefore, we conclude that a nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility, thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output.