Topper Copies

In demand for money, what are the major differences between 'transaction approach' and 'cash balance approach'?

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The Classical School Economists gave two interpretations of same mathematical form of money relationship; first by Fischer & later by Rigou - marshall (Cambridge)

Fischer Initially, an identity was given: M V̄ ≡ P T - Product of money Supply with velocity of money - Nominal value of Transactions for all good (Σti) - V̄ : considered constant in S.R. as it depended upon many factors like Banking habits, financial technologies, etc.

later; the modified form was: M V̄ = P Y_f (QTM) - only current Full Empt Income needs were considered.

Thus, there was direct & Equi-proportional linkage between money Supply and Price levels of Economy.

Later, the theory was modified by Cambridge Economists

M V̄ = P y_F

M^d = K̄ (P y_F) (Cash Balance Approach)

They argued that individuals would hold/demand money in a proportion to their nominal Income (K̄) (P. y_F)

This proportion was however fixed & exogenously given.

Both the above theories were severly criticized for their assumpⁿ as they have assumed full Empt. (y_F)

Friedman later restated the Cambridge version ( & dropped Y=Y_f and argued that k was endogenously determined ).

Summing up :

Differences

| Fischer | Cambridge version | |---|---| | 1. Actually a theory of M^ss and not of money demand. | 1. Considered to be Ist theory of md (although not comprehensive) | | 2. This holds policy prescription for central Banks. | 2. Focussed upon Behavioral aspect of individuals. | | 3. Focus upon V (velocity) | 3. Focus upon k (proportionality) |

However, in theory (mathematically), both approaches are similar; they both assume Y=Y_f & took inspiration from classical thoughts.