Topper Copies

Distinguish between pure public goods, private goods and mixed goods. In which way can one achieve Pareto optimality when an economy provides private and public goods? Discuss.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Goods can be classified based upon the criteria of Excludability & Rivalry.

Excludable means that a person can be prevented from consuming it

Rival means that a consumption by others would deplete the amount available for a person.

| | Excludable: Yes | Excludable: No | |---|---|---| | Rival: Yes | Pure Private | Congestion goods | | Rival: No | Club goods | Pure public |

Fig : spectrum of classification (a diagonal strip labelled mixed runs between the cells)

Pure public Goods

Non Rival & Non Excludable goods. for ex: Defence, Doordarshan.

They follow vertical summation of Individual demand curves.

[a graph of price against quantity with demand lines DA and DB, their vertical sum D(A+B), and MC meeting at e, with Q* on the quantity axis]

This is because the amount of Oty. produced would be same for everyone (Q*) and all the people would contribute towards its provision.

Pure Private Goods

Fully excludible, fully rival Ex: A limited edition luxury yatch.

This follows horizontal summation of Dd curves. Price paid by each individual would be same & total oty. produced would get distributed as per Individual dd.

[a graph of price against quantity with demand lines DA and DB, their horizontal sum DA+B, and MC meeting at e at price Pi; Q* = QA + QB]

Mixed Goods

Ex: Clubs, Roads, etc. ] Neither fully Pvt/Public

Pareto Optimality (when Public + Private Good)

Panel (i) depicts the PPF of the Economy. Panel (ii) depicts Indiff. curve A

[three panels: (i) a PPF with IC_A, (ii) indifference curves IC_A^3, IC_A^1, IC_A^2, (iii) the equilibrium of B with IC_B]

Panel (iii) depicts the Eqm decision of B

Panel (i)

Given the PPF of Economy, the position of IC_A determine the amount of Private goods available for B to consume

But, the Public- Private bundle that is derived on point of Eq^m; depicts the same qty of public good which'd be left for everyone to consume (equally).

Based on panel (i), we derive the consumption possibility for B (wrt (panel iii) private good). B's Eqm is not at its highest pt. P but slightly right from it. The e_B thus derived is plotted back to panel (i) where out of cm private goods, B consumes mn and A takes nc.

oc amount of public good is available to all equally.

Thus, this is a condition of eqm where in neither party has any incentive to change their consm decisions and each are optimizing accordingly.