What do you mean by statutory and economic incidence of a tax? Explain the role of elasticity of demand and supply in distribution of burden of a product tax between buyers and sellers. Are there any other factors that influence the economic incidence a tax?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Statutory Incidence refers to the question as to upon which agent buyer/seller the tax has been imposed upon & thus they are mandated to submit the tax amount to the Exchequer.
However; it necessarily doesn't depict the actual burden sharing of the tax; that is represented by Economic Incidence of tax i.e. the ultimate proportion in which tax amount needs to be shared/borne (irrespective of who collects & submits it)
Generally;
Buyer's burden / seller's Burden = E.S. / E.D.
Agent's burden is inversely related to their respective elasticities.
Illustration 1
let Per unit tax is imposed on seller
[a supply-demand graph with shifted supply SS' and demand DD, equilibria e_1 and e_2, price levels P_b, P_1, P_s]
Fig: Elastic dd & ss
Buyer's burden = P_b P_1 a e_2
seller's burden = P_1 P_s b a
Illustration 2
[a supply-demand graph with steep supply SS and flatter demand DD, the buyer's share thin and the seller's burden large]
Fig: Inelastic supply - Higher Burden on seller
Illustration 3
[a supply-demand graph with flat supply SS and steep demand dd, the buyer's burden large and the seller's thin]
Fig: Inelastic dd - Higher Burden upon buyer
However; Elasticity of Dd & ss are not the sole determinants of respective shares of Tax Incidence.
Other factors:
1. time Horizon - In short Run, supply is Inelastic & sellers can't easily alter production ∴ Seller bears higher share. 2. market structure - In a monopoly, buyers share higher burden of tax... 3. cost matrix of supplier In a decreasing cost f^n, as Qty falls, cost of prod^n ↑ ⇒ Burden on buyer ↑ (as Price ↑) [a small downward-sloping curve with a double-headed arrow under the horizontal axis] 4. nature of tax - Indirect taxes generally get shifted more to buyers.
Thus, a range of factors affect Tax Burden...