“Transaction demand for money is interest rate elastic.” Explain in reference to the post-Keynesian theories of demand for money.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Keynesian Theory of Liquidity Preference was severely criticized for making transaction demand of money in sensitive to interest rate : L^d = ky - hi - ky is marked m_t, f(y) - hi is marked m_sp.
The optimal Cash Balance Approach (Inventory theory) rose up as a stark challenge to the keynesian proposal.
model :
Let an Individual spends ₹ y monthly. He withdraws this amount in beginning of each month & uses it till month end (assume)
then, avg. cash balance = y/2 [(y-0)/2] opening Bal. - closing Bal. 2
for N withdrawals per month; cash Balance Avg. = y/2N
This behaviour is so because there are shoeleather costs & costs of Interest foregone by not keeping money in Bank
Shoeleather cost = F.N (F per transaction)
Interest cost = (y/2N) . i
Σ cost = FN + (y/2N) i
For optimality; ∂C/∂N = 0 => F - (yi/2)(1/N²) = 0 => F = yi/2N² => N² = yi/2F => N = √(y.i/2F) (optimum no. of transaction monthly)
∴ Putting this value into optimal Avg. Cash Balance; y/2N, we get
optimal cashholding = y / (2 √(y·i / 2F))
M_t^D = (√y √F) / (√2 √i) = √(yF / 2i)
Thus,
transactionary demand for money
M_t = f ( y, F, i ) + + −
Therefore, it was not interest insensitive ; rather interest rates affected it negatively as the opp. cost of money holding got higher as interest rates increased.