Topper Copies

Explain the decentralization theorem in context of welfare gains from multiple fiscal units. How do individuals vote by their feet?

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The decentralization theorem argues in favour of having a federal structure : multiple fiscal units, because there are some decisions which are best taken place at decentralized level.

I model :

Assumptions :

1. The Entire nation is subdivided into 2 localities : A and B (L_A) (L_B) 2. Each locality is represented by x and y respectively. 3. Cost of providing public good is homogenous across country. 4. Freedom of movement across nation is guaranteed.

Suppose, Residents of LA demand Dx qty. and LB demand Dy qty. of public good.

[a graph of cost against quantity, with a horizontal line MC_i, demand lines Dx and Dy, and quantities Qy, Q0 and Qx marked]

For given cost matrix, Qx and Qy should be provided to them respectively.

But now, suppose that central government intervenes and provides a uniform qty Q0 to both localities.

This is a poor outcome: LA residents were willing to pay aby extra for provision of Qx. LB residents were willing to pay only for Qy and now axc is being extra demanded by govt.

The calls for an arrangement wherein local public goods should be provided by local authorities who can better estimate the demands of the local population.

Voting by feet

- Individuals can freely migrate to other locality which can meet their demands sufficiently ( LA people can migrate to LB as the demands in LA were not met and LB people got more then demanded) Thus, they can migrate accordingly.

Another explanation is with respect to local taxation. If LA imposes any tax to Provide public goods then people who are unwilling to Pay can move to other locality, thereby revealing their preferences

However; this is one such aspect which necessitates the presence of a central govt. If the govt. want to redistribute Income (by say imposing wealth tax) then local governments won't be successful until they are coordinated.

Thus, a central govt. only can impose a functional nation wide tax system (& it would be difficult to escape, because people would then have to leave country & that is not very easy in daily lives).

Thus; although there is need of a powerful Centre; yet there are gains (savings from DWL) arising out of multiple Fiscal Units.