“Simplicity of the Quantity Theory of Money is its strength as well as its weakness.” Discuss.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Quantity Theory was given by Fischer as Policy suggestion for Central Banks to regulate the rates of money supply in the Economy as to achieve financial stability.
Af Fischer; MV̄ ≡ P.T Initially, an identity was given, which related moneysupply times velocity with nominal value of all (past + present transactions) However; later, it was reiterated as MV̄ = PY_f velocity constant only current year's full empt. level Income was to be considered. Strength! This was fairly easy for central Banks to understand & act upon Stability of money supply.
Weaknesses of Theory
1. It was not a theory of money demand but of m.s. 2. Assumes y = y_f (Classical perogative) 3. Considers money neutrality - monetarists criticized this and said money supply can affect output at least in S.Run. 4. velocity stability was sometimes found to be unstable due to financial innovation & Economic cycles, etc.
Thus; the theory's simplicity was its strength as well as its weakness.