Topper Copies

What is meant by equity in taxation? How do you justify for the ability to pay approach as a tool in achieving equity?

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Equity is a desirable situation where-in the burden & returns are shared in a justified manner as per some well defined ethical arguments.

Benefits Principle argues that the tax system should be such designed that the person who gains the most out of the Public Expenditure, also pays the maximum share (in accordance to benefits)

This is accepted because tax is such designed that it plays the same role which is played by Prices in Private Transactions ..

Despite Efficiency argument, this approach falls short of the Equity argument: The maximum benefits of Public Expenditure is shared by the most downtrodden sections & this doesn't justify putting a high share of tax upon them (against DPSP and Equity Approach)

Thus, the Ability to pay approach took greater precedence and it must satisfy: Horizontal & vertical equity Equal Ability to pay => Equal burden If person 1 has more ability to pay, his burden is more

Thus; the approach of Ability being more Equitable.