Topper Copies

Is Friedman’s quantity theory of money close to Classical or Keynesian approach to the aggregate demand for money? Given justifications for your arguments.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Friedman reinstated the Classical QTM which was given by the Cambridge Economists. However, it also contains a unique Keynesian aspect.

Classical QTM (Cambridge)

M^d = K̄ (P y_f)

i.e. A proportion of nominal money was demanded as cash Balance by Individuals to ease their transactions. They assumed y = y_f and K (Proportionality) was exogenous.

However, Friedman rejected the above two assumptions of QTM and also incorporated the Keynesian critique of QTM in his theory.

Keynes had criticized QTM for accounting md as only for being transactionary purposes. the classical failed to account it for its store of value (as an asset).

Friedman also rejected y = y_F : As per him, monetary Policy only can help output grow beyond Full Empt. Eq^m but, only for short Run ( & not in long run).

Now, K was to be determined by a plethora of variables ( & thus, not be taken as exogenously as per Classical thesis) :

K = f( r_e, r_b, h, i, PA, etc.)

- r_e : Returns of Equity ∝ 1/m^d - r_b : Return on Bond ∝ 1/m^d - h: Human capital level α md - i: Interest Rate α 1/md - PA: Return on physical Assets/md

Thus; Friedman's restated QTM m^s = m^d = k ( _ _ _ ). Py k: stable

As per him; in short Run, (P.y) changes where Δy > ΔP but in Long Run, only ΔP & Δy=0

Thus, Friedman's demand for money theory although takes the functional form of QTM; but incorporates important Keynesian facets too.