Topper Copies

What do you mean by balanced budget? What are the arguments for and against balanced budget?

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Balanced Budget refers to a phenomenon where in the govt. Expenditure & tax Revenue change equi-proportionately in same direction s.t. there is no deficit, no surplus; i.e. G = T

Arguments for :

1. Fiscal health & Fiscal prudence - spending as per the size of the coffers. 2. Intergenerational Equity: not overburdening the future generations by overspending today. 3. Barro-Ricardo Hypothesis: citizens are smart Enough to predict the future burdens of increase in Govt. spending today. 4. Higher deficit today gets rolled over to tomorrow's deficit pressures.

Arguments Against:

1. Blanchard's IRGD - As long as r < g i.e. Economy grows faster than the interest burden; govt. debt is sustainable. 2. Joseph Stiglitz - If govt. can create enough avenues to incentivize savings (tax benefits, dedicated Institutions) then G>T is not an issue

Ultimately, it is the Quality of the debt that matters. As long as Capex is increasing and Revenue/ less useful expenditures are under Control; debt is highly sustainable as shown by India's recent experience.