"Why have land reforms in India faced persistent challenges? Discuss the obstacles and their implications."
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Based upon recommendations of S. Kumarappa committee; land Reforms were carried out across 4 domains:
1. Abolition of Intermediaries - only the Rights of Zamindars to collect Taxes could be removed; - However, the excess lands could not be taken away due to: - (a) lack of land Records - (b) Poor Political will (PS Appu) - (c) Loosely worded law (Provision of 'personal cultivation') 2. Land ceiling - - As per PS Appu ; only 2% of the target could be achieved. - Benami Transactions reduced the efficiency. 3. Tenancy Reforms - only around 4% of Tenants could be suitably rehabilitated (PS Appu) - many states failed to recognize Share croppers as Tenants, delayed legislation, etc. 4. Land consolidation - less than 1/3rd of the plan could be achieved
Implications
1. continued poverty (As per FAO; further 5% Land Reforms would lead to over 30% decline of Poverty) 2. Social Injustice, Inequality (violates DPSP of Constitution)
Way Ahead
1. Focus on 3 aspects
2. Implementing SWAMITVA scheme FRUITS of Karnataka Govt: Case study
As per Tajmul Haque; Land Reforms are critical need of them; LARR Act, 2013 should be properly implemented to begin with.