"To what extent did import substitution industrialization (ISI) policies contribute to India's economic development during the 1950s and 1960s? Discuss its effectiveness and implications for industrial growth."
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
The 2nd 5-year Plan (1956-61) envisaged a policy of Import substituting Industrialization as one of its key objectives. This formed the cornerstone of IPR, 1956
17 key, basic & heavy industries were reserved for Public sector (Sch. A)
Contribution in Economic developmt
I. GDP growth - The avg. growth turned out to be ~ 4.1% p.a. for Ist 3 5 yr plans (more than targeted) - Along with a population growth of ~ 2% p.a; per capita production increased by over 2% p.a.
II. Industrial Growth
Industrial growth during Nehruvian regime was around ~5.6% p.a. capital goods Industry grew the most ; often breaching double digits.
g capital goods > g Intermediate goods > g overall Industry > g GDP (Trend during Nehruvian years)
III. Industrial Diversification - Before IPR, 1956; less than 15 final commodities were produced by public sector. - By 1991, 8000+ varities were produced.
IV. Industrial mix
The policy of Import substitution, helped to absorb some surplus labour from Agriculture into Industry ; & from less than 1% share of modern Industry in India's employment (in 1951); it gradually grew to 4% by LPG reforms time.
[a line graph of % share of GDP against time (1950s, 1991, today) with three dashed lines: services rising from 29% to 43% to 53%, Industry from 18% to 29% to 30%, and Agri. falling from 53% to 28% to 17%]
V. Dual Gap management
India had low savings (~10% in 1951) and low Forex Reserves; coupled with the phenomena of Export Pessimism. As per Pulapre Balakrishnan , the I-S-I policy was the need of the hour to grow resources for future expansion.
VI. Infra creation
Using the Unbalanced Growth theory of Hirschman; increase in DPA (Directly Productive Avenues) compelled the state to produce more (SOC: social overhead Capital)
[a graph of power generation against time, 2300 mw near 1951 rising by a dashed line to 1 lakh mw at 1991]
over 1,00,000+ km of metalled Road (1950 - 1991)
However, Import substituting Industrialization has been criticized upon following :
(*) vakil-Brahmanand - hold the policy to be responsible for heavy inflation (which was suppressed by Administered Pricing) - failure to generate sufficient Employment. - shortage of necessity goods. - Dependence upon Russian technology and foreign Aid.
[a price against quantity graph with vertical supply lines AS (wage goods) at Y1 and AS' (wage goods) at Y2, a downward-sloping AD curve, and price falling from P1 to P2]
Thus, I-S-I policy had a mixed Contribution towards Industrial & Economic growth.