Topper Copies

The restrictions imposed under Article 293 of the Constitution on State borrowing powers, though constitutionally valid, may hinder fiscal autonomy of States and disrupt cooperative federalism. Discuss in the light of recent developments.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Article 293 restrictions on borrowing powers stem out of "off-budget borrowings" that call NK Singh Committee regulations.

Cooperative Federation + Fiscal autonomy hindered

1. State prerogative and fiscal deprevement - (eg) fetters on Article 293 go after state PSUs 2. States demand "federalism" in fiscal discipline - (eg) demand for easing foreign borrowing 3. GST compensation lag quoted as reason of state-funds cut down - (eg) "destination based" tax affects South disproportionately 4. Inability to feed basic programme expenditures with mounting debt - (eg) Punjab ranked lowest by RBI State Finance Report 5. Central tied grants mania -> states unsettled with demands 6. Rising cases of lack of central devolution in Centrally Sponsored Schemes - (eg) Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan Funds & Tamil Nadu 7. Fiscal discipline calculus haywire

[a bar chart showing a rising fiscal deficit]

However, this is Constitutionally valid:

1. Centre within ambit of Article 293 2. FRBM Act consideration of fiscal discipline as guide 3. Need to cut on unconditional welfarism important -> social infrastructure focus 4. Introduction of "competitive federalism" for higher grants 5. NK Singh Committee recommend suggestions in lieu

Way forward

1. Cooperative fiscal federalism to ensure state finance health 2. Innovative PPP models for financing and operation - (eg) GPL model 3. Austerity measures 4. Public Finance Management System introduction (2nd FRC)

Thus, with "bargaining federalism" as our model, there is a need to enhance the pie and follow Finance Commission guidelines.