What do the Cournot and Bertrand models have in common? What are the differences between these two models?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Cournot and Bertrand models are the two different approaches to market equilibrium under Duopoly setups where in Firms reach towards their Nash Equilibriums and neither of the firms have any incentive to deviate from that level.
A) Cournot model
The modern Cournot Approach uses Reaction curves derived from the Iso-profit curves of the two sellers.
[a graph of two downward-sloping reaction curves R.C.1 and R.C.2 crossing at E, the Cournot Nash, with Q1 on the horizontal and Q2 on the vertical axis]
The intersection of two R.C.'s Provide us the Cournot Nash equilibrium that is stable.
The RCs are downward sloping depicting as quantity produced by a particular supplier increases, its profits increase proportionately.
B) Bertrand model
In this case, the B.R. curves are +vely sloped; indicating higher Prices leading into increased profits.
[a graph of two upward-sloping best response curves B.R.f ① and B.R.f ② crossing at the Bertrand Nash, with P1 on the horizontal and P2 on the vertical axis]
The simultaneous intersection of B.R.F. curves provides us Bertrand Nash of Price Equilibrium which is a state of stability too.
Similarities
1. Both models assume naive behavior by firms that they do not learn from their past mistakes for failing to accomodate the behavior of their competitors while determining own Price / qty. (This is challenged by Baumol) 2. Both models are closed in the sense that Entry is not permitted once the firms start to each other. 3. Both models fail to predict a satisfactory time duration within which adjustments could get complete. 4. In both models, both firms try to maximize their Individual profits and not joint profits. 5. In both models, we have simultaneous Negotiations in (either price or Qty) and both firms together determine the market stability.
Differences
1. In cournot model, firms engage in Quantity competition and both of them try to capture a larger share of market. vs. In Bertrand setup, firms try to compete in prices and outcompete the opposition firm. 2. In cournot, the B.R.F. (Reaction curves) are downward sloping. vs. In Bertrand; the R.C.s are upward sloping (although Equilibrium in both cases is stable) 3. Leadership conditions - Cournot : If a firm undertakes Qty. leadership by (incorporating Qty. BRF of firm 2 in its profit function); called Top Dog model; it is able to produce more than its competitor and earn more profits. - vs. Bertrand : If Price leadership is undertaken; called Puppy Dog strategy → actually the first mover firm which reveals its prices prior hand stands at risk of getting it outmatched (even lower price being charged by its competitor & taking more market share).
Thus; the similarity & differences between both model.