Does a monopolistically competitive market lead to excess capacity under price competition?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
A monopolistic market is featured by a large number of firms, each producing differentiated products (whereby lending it a slight degree of market power)
However, monopolistic competition has been criticized for its failure to being able to optimally utilize the society's resources and that too many, too small firms create high wastage of resources.
general view (Stigler) optimal production is achieved wherein firms are producing at ACmin.
[a graph of a U-shaped AC, MC cutting AC at its minimum, and a horizontal AR=MR line, with Q*P.C marked]
However, in monopolistic firm the Qm is left to Q*PC ; thereby indicating Excess capacity
[a graph of a U-shaped AC with ACmin and a downward-sloping demand curve, with Qm and Q*P.C marked]
Chamberlin's critique
→ If a Firm competes in prices, there exists free entry and downward sloping AR; then there exists no Excess capacity in monopolistic market.
→ The gap (Qm - Q*) is the social cost wherein buyers are willing to pay a higher price for product differentiation and choices for them.
[a graph of dd, DD and a U-shaped AC with ACmin, with Qi, Qm and Q marked, E.C. between Qi and Qm and social cost between Qm and Q]
However, if firms compete in non-price competition; then the DD (Proportional) gains relevance and in that case, Excess Capacity exists.
And Thus, no Excess Capacity under Price competition.