"If firms produce differentiated products it is neither possible to identify the industry nor possible to draw its supply curve." Discuss and show how Chamberlin handles the problem.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Chamberlin highlighted that due to high product differentiation, it was 'impossible to draw market supply curve as different g-types of commodities couldn't be added together.
Chamberlin, thus undertook a few Heroic assumptions to simplify the analysis :
1. Product Groups : Instead of Industry where commonly produced goods are sold, the idea behind Product groups was to categorize similar feature goods ; Products must be the technical & Economic substitutes for being able to be accomodated in a particular group . 2. same cost structure : Despite all firms producing similar commodities Chamberlin, for simplicity assumed MC of all firms be same . 3. Equal market share of all the firms despite customer choices & product differentiation. S₁ = S₂ = S₃ ... Sᵢ: share of each firm in Industry
3 models
1. Entry allowed 2. Price Adjustment 3. Entry + Price adjst
Example : case① market Entry Allowed In this case, P₁ > PE due to super normal profit, entry of outsider firms and AR for each firm shifts back until Normal profits are realized.
[a graph of MC, AC, AR(dd) and MR with price levels P1 and C1 and quantity Q*]
Thus, chamberlin could solve the dilemma of lack of Industry supply and even the definition of Industry itself.