Compare and contrast the Fisher's equation of money and the Cambridge equation of money. Analyze the usefulness of these equations in understanding and managing monetary policy in the context of controlling inflation and promoting economic stability.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Two branches of classical schools : one under Fischer and the other comprisiy of Cambridge Economists saw their theories getting popular lost money :
I. Fischer QTM
Initially, Fischer gave the identity which related the value of total Transactions to the quantum of money supplied multiplied by the Turnover rate of currency.
MV ≡ P.T
later, the Identity was transformed into an equation
MV̄ = P.y_f
That implied existence of a direct and proportionate relationship between money supply and price level in the economy (if V: velocity is assumed constant and y=y_f as per classical thought)
V̄ : could be modified in L.R. by Banking interventions, etc
Using log and differentiating,
% change in Ms = % Change in Prices
Thus, the stability of money supply by the Central Bank was considered to be of utmost importance in Controlling Inflation and overall macroEconomic stability.
II. Cambridge / Cash Balance Approach
→ The Economists like marshall, Pigou lamented over the QTM's inability to focus upon money demand in the Economy.
→ They argued that although money doesn't yield any Real Returns; yet it was crucial for aiding in transaction purposes.
Thus, QTM was changed into
Md = K. PY
That is the Individuals keep a certain fraction of their nominal Incomes as cash Balance.
The nominal Income of an Individual serves as a good indicator about the Transactions demand needed by an Individual. Thus, central Bank must also take into consideration the money demand for money market equilibrium and overall stability.
Shortcomings
1. Hicks and Hansen : Argued that instead of nominal demand, Individuals also consider Real Balances. 2. Price levels in both approaches wasn't adequately defined. 3. consideration of y=y_f even in Short Run was contested by Friedman. 4. narrow focus only upon the transaction demand and ignorance of money demand as an Asset was put forth by Keynes.