Does government borrowing always crowd out private investment? Illustrate
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Crowding out refers to a situation wherein the funds availability and the cost of obtaining it significantly deteriorates for the private firms due to rise in Government Expenditure.
[two graphs: an investment demand curve I = I̅ - bi with interest rate rising from i1 to i2 (Fig: crowding out), and a loanable fund market with supply, two demand curves and the crowding-out gap marked C.O. (Fig: Loanable fund market)]
factors affecting crowding out
1. slope of Investment curve (b) - more steeper it is, less is the crowding out 2. slope of Lm curve - more flatter it is, less is the c.out as interest rate increment is minimal. 3. Slope of IS curve - Higher the slope, lesser crowding out
Conditions of no crowding out
1. If Government asks Central Bank for deficit finance and not disturb the loanable fund market
[a loanable funds graph with demand shifting from LFd1 to LFd2 at an unchanged interest rate]
2. Investment subsidy to help the pvt. firms with interest rate increase
[an investment demand graph, I = I̅ - bi, with a parallel shifted line]
3. As per Derberg & McDougall ; if the Govt. can sufficiently increase domestic savings, then crowding out can be limited.
Thus, crowding out is contextual and not necessarily omnipresent.