Topper Copies

7. (a) When is it more effective to pursue a Hirschmanian strategy compared to Nurksian balanced growth model approach? Discuss after explaining the essence of both the models.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

while Hirschman favored unbalanced strategy of growth, Nurkse & Rodan vouched for a more balanced growth.

Hirschman Theory

Book: Dissenter's Confession

- The theory argues that we need to initially prioritize those sectors which have the maximum linkages in the society. - The Gains reaped by promoting those sectors would later be reinvested into other sectors, thereby keeping the growth alive & embarking upon: "Growth as a chain of multiple Dis Equilibria." - He argues that in initial stages of development when countries lack a strong fiscal cushion, this Strategy is more practical for them.

Initially, the growth/Investment can take following 2 patterns:

1. Approach : SOC > DPA

If govt invests into SOC (OA'); this would eventually crowd in Private Investment as Economy moves to Point A.

[graph of DPA against SOC with a 45-degree Balanced path, curves SIC1 and SIC2, and points A, A' and A"] 2. Approach DPA → SOC (OA" → A)

If Pvt. sector invests in a particular sector; it would push the govt. into creating more Infra for that sector.

SOC: Social Overhead Capital (Common-haste Infra)

DPA : Direct Productive Activity (Pvt. Invst)

SOC provides more +ve Externality than it appropriates (& vice versa for DPA)

Nurkse & Rodan

Argues for a Balanced growth path: simultaneous investment in all sectors of Economy (mfg, Agri, etc.)

Argument : "If all 20,000 workers of Economy are put only into shoe factory, they won't only demand shoes and this will generate heavy inflationary pressure for all sectors of Economy."

- They also argue about Indivisibility of Investment : Bits & Pieces approach fails to generates returns and a sizable Initial Lump is read. to sustainably grow a desired Economic mix. - However Leibenstein Criticized this theory in his 'critical minimum Effort' theory.

Temporal desirability

- Both Balanced & unbalanced strategies are not substitutes, but complements to each other. - However, it is argued that during Initial stages of growth, a country should Prioritize its strategically imp. sector with max linkages as there is Resource crunch.

They both assume interdependence of SOC & DPA to some or other extent)

(Eg: IPR 2.0)

- As the Economy progresses; all sector needs equitable focus from govt. (Ex: Agri → PM-FBY, NFSM, etc. Industry → PLI, NMP, etc. services → BPO Promotion, etc.)