6. (b) Explain the Ranis-Fei model of economic development. How does it improve upon the Lewis model of development?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Lewis model was considered to be an incomprehensive model as it failed to explain certain basic tenets like growth dynamics of traditional sector, etc.
Simple Lewis model
Assumption
1. Dualism: Traditional Agri / modern Ind. 2. In Agri ( w = AP_L ) 3. In Industry ( w = mp_L ) 4. surplus labour
Theory
The focus is upon explaining the transformation of an Economy from predominant Traditional sector towards a moden Indust sector
model
The model argues that if Industrialists are able to extract workers from Agri, by paying them a slightly higher wage w,
[graph of wages & profit against labour with downward-sloping curves Ld, Ld^2, Ld^3, a horizontal wage line w1, and L1, L2, L3 marked]
Then gradually, the surplus labour of Agri. could get transferred to more productive Industrial sector. As production improves, the surplus available with Industrialist increases (as his mps is high); this further gets reinvested and labour is extracted out of Agri. as until surplus is over (at constant w1 > w)
Ranis-Fei Improvement
Lewis had failed : 1. to explain why wages in Industrial sector wouldn't rise gradually 2. growth / transition of traditional sector
It argues that as more labour is drawn out of Agri; the wages paid to them must improve (w1 rises)
Stage I
MPL of Agri worker =0. Industrialist for now can extract as many worker if wants at prevailing w1.
[graph of Ind. wages against Ind. Labour in Phase I, Phase II and Phase III, with a flat wage line w1 and Pts. of Inflection]
Stage II
Now, MPL of worker in Agri. turns +ve and wage rate starts to rise in Industry
[graph of Returns against Ind. labour with regions MPL=0 (Excess labour), MPL>0 (Disguised unempl) and MPL rises (commercializ. of Agri.)]
Stage III
This stage marks the commercialization of Agri. as all surplus labour is taken out and workers get paid @ MPL.
[graph of Agri surplus against labour]
Fig: 3- phased L-R-F model
Thus, the improvement of Ranis-Fei over simple Lewis model.