6. (a) The Harrod-Domar growth model states that a country 'growth rate of per capita income depends on its rate of savings, whereas the Solow growth model predict that a higher saving rate is incapable of leading to sustained long-run per-capita economic growth in the absence of technical progress. Explain these assertions.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Harrod-Domar & solow model differed heavily upon the role (ability) of savings to explain sustained Economic growth.
Harrod Domar
Assumptions
1. Dual nature of Investment (Accelerator & multiplier) (ss) (Dd) 2. Given θ : k/y ratio 3. Given s (savings rate) 4. Based on Keynesian Ideology 5. Initial full-Emp. Eqm
model
g = s/θ − n − δ
growth rate is directly proportional to savings rate (and indirectly to θ, δ and n)
why was this occuring?
1. Due to H-D assumption that θ is given exogenously & that it doesn't change; any rise in savings led to perpetual growth 2. Because every new investment would be equally productive and due to this constancy, the growth in GDP (& per capita GDP) is also constantly high.. 3. Also, the dual nature of Investment has a big role to play: Investment enhances the productive capacity & also enhances demand (by enhancing Income)
Thus; For H-D, savings rate increment is the ultimate panacea of growth.
Solow
Solow thesis : savings causes growth, but it is only temporarily in the sense that growth occurs only until Economy reaches a new steady state and after that,
g_K, g_y, g_k, g_y = 0
Assumptions
1. σ is determined Endogenously.. (as economy matures, ICOR rises)
[graph of y against k with a concave curve y=f(k)] 2. Diminishing returns to factor
[graph of g against k with a rising line s.k and two concave curves s'.y and s₁.y, steady states k* and k*_new marked; and a graph of g against savings with a flat line stepping up, labelled level effect]
Fig: Savings in solow model cause only level effect
Solow argued that even labour force growth by itself can't help to explain sustained growth in capital & Income (per capita basis)
(gk, gy = 0)
It is at only the exogenously given technical progress, which could explain perpetual growth
(gk, gy = n+g gk, gy = g)
[graph of g against t, a gently rising line that steepens sharply at a point, with dashed lines]
Fig: Growth Effect of Technological progress.
However, later both these models were criticized for lack of consideration of Human Capital which could help in explaining perpetual growth