Distinguish between ‘Internal Rate of Return (IRR)’ and ‘Net Present Value (NPV)’ criteria of evaluating public investment projects. What is the role of shadow prices in this context?
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
NPV, IRR and shadow Prices are tools of financial planning that aid investors in cost benefit analysis.
NPV
NPV = — cost Expenditure (Initially) + Discounted Cash flows (DCF) + Disposal value of Asset
wherein DCF = Σ (i=1 to n) x / (1+r)^n x: Annual Income r: Rate of discounting
NPV approach argues that until NPV >= 0; the project is not advisable and it would create more loss than gains.
IRR
It is that discount factor / Rate of interest which makes NPV atleast zero. The more the IRR the better it is.
Shadow Prices
It is often used for developing nations or wherein there are incomplete input markets which fail to depict the true values of factor prices.
Eg:
[two side-by-side supply-demand graphs: wages against L with D_L, S_L and a w_min line above w_E; int. rate against K with D_K, S_K and an r_max line below r_E]
fig: min. wage laws distort true signalling of factor price fig: Rent caps also hinder native signalling
Shadow Prices can be computed via General/Partial Eqm approach and is critical to make informed choices.