Topper Copies

It is sometimes observed that a country's current account worsens immediately after a real currency depreciation and begins to improve only sometimes later. This phenomenon is popularly represented by J-curve. Explain the phenomenon.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The J curve effect argues that following a devaluation (depreciation) BOP immediately worsens, but gradually improves later on.

Assumptions :

1. No wage price spiral 2. Presence of Excess capacity 3. M-L condition holds |Εx| + |Εm| > 1

model

[a graph of BOP against time, with a curve dipping to a trough and then rising above a dashed line, a dotted continuation labelled Samuelson's Hysteria, and a label on the time axis near the origin that is unclear]

The J-curve happens out of interaction between value Effect and volume Effect.

Short Run

Both Exports & Imports are relatively inelastic. But due to devaluation, Import burden shots up significantly (value effect) without a proportionate jump in Exports (volume effect).

Thus, trade balance worsens immediately.

Gradually,

Exports pick-up as world gets more awareness about nation's cheaper exports and volume effect now dominates value effects.

BoP = Px . Qx + Pm . Qm with small arrows beneath the terms: down under Px, up under Qx, up under Pm, down under Qm

(And imports fall due to Expenditure switching in favour of domestic goods by residents).

Samuelson's hysteria argues that world continues to trade with country which devalued its currency initially, even after price dynamics fizzle up.

The M-L condition is of extreme significance : elasticities of Import & Export must be higher in gradual terms otherwise value effect continues to dominate.

India's 1966 Devaluation failed because our |Em| was very low due to Import of Technical goods for N-M plan and we lacked export capacity : poor |Ex| & |Ex| + |Em| < 1