'A nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility (at constant prices), thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output. However fiscal policy is fully effective in this case' . Do you agree? Explain.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Mundell Flemming model argues about ineffectiveness of monetary Policy in fixed E.R. system ( & even an existence of Policy Trilemma)
Assumptions
1. Fixed E.R. 2. Free capital flows (BP is flat)
model :
[an IS-LM-BP graph with int. rate against output, i = if and BP=0 through E1, IS and LM1 (M1/P1) meeting at E1, dashed LM2 (M2/P1) cutting IS at E2, and y1 on the output axis]
Assuming initially Economy was at E1. when Central Bank goes for monetary Expansion (LM1 → LM2) Excess money supply causes i < if leading to Capital outflows, and Pressurizing domestic currency to depreciates. But central Bank intervenes : Buys domestic currency & sells foreign currency This contracts LM back to its original position. Thereby, Fully ineffective monetary Policy and rather central Bank is no more independent in taking M.P. decisions.
However, Fiscal Policy is fully efficient in fixed E.R. Case. when govt. undertakes fisc. expansion (IS1 ——> IS2) This causes i > if and leads to k - Inflow & pressure upon domestic currency to appreciate.
[an IS-LM-BP graph with IS1 and IS2, LM1 and LM2 (dashed), i = if and BP=0, points E1, E2 and E3, and y1 and y2 on the output axis]
To prevent this in fixed E.R., central Bank supplies domestic currency and (LM₁ → LM₂). Ultimately i = if is reattained but economy is at a higher output level, showing full Fiscal Effectiveness.