3(c) Explain in brief the findings of McClelland in the field of motivation & its relation to economic development. What are the criticism of McClelland's emphasis of nAch on eco develop.
Ravi Jain
McCleland was pioneer in find the role of achievement motivation in economic development. He worked on the theory of Max Webber as given in 'The Proletarian'. McCleland believed that the development of a society or a nation is dependent on the Need for Achievement. Need for Achievement is a driving force which motivates an individual towards achievement of goal against some standard of excellence. He held that this nAch was a social motive and was develop created in early childhood during mastery training and achievement training. Thus nAch is influenced by culture of the society and Child Rearing Practices (CRPs). He believed that nAch can be created in groups and individual through training. This was demonstrated by McClelland and Winter in this training programme in Kakinada.
The criticism of McCleland's emphasis of achievement motivation. 1. JBP Sinha held that nAch will lead to development in society where there is sufficiency of resource. eg- in the western Countries. In countries like India, where there is scarcity of resource, need for achievement will lead to conflict. And development in these countries can be achieved through cooperation and collaboration. 2. Pareek agreed with this line of thought and gave the formula for development -
D = AM x EM - DM
where AM is achievement Motivation EM is extension Motivation - which means extention of self to to society DM is dependency Motivation.
Pareek held that alone AM will not ensure success. & High AM should be accompanied by Low DM and High EM 3. D Sinha. believed that achievement is different in different culture. like in western country it is individualistic Achievement whereas in India it is collective achievement 4. JBP Sinha held that mere nAch may ensure entrepeneurial behavior but will not ensure success and development depends on societal And institutional factor.
Though McCleland's theory has certain limitation but it can be held that AM promotes development.