2(c) Where do you find yourself between Chomsky vs Skinner debate on development of language in humans ? Justify your view with suitable examples.
Ravi Jain
Language is a system of symbols and sounds that when combined according to some rules produces meaning which is intelligible to all the speakers.
The process of language acquisition is explained differently by empiricist (like Skinner) and nativist (like Leneberg & Chomsky)
Chomsky's Theory of language acquisition
(i) He believed the role of environment in development process. (ii) According to him, language acquisition takes place using the process of Instrumental Conditioning. (iii) The process is facilitated by reward, punishment, generalization, discrimination. (IV) The process of Chaining helps in language acquisition through successive approximations. (V) It involves process of - Tacts, Mands, Autoclitis, Echoic, intraverbal.
Chomky's Theory of Language Acquisition
Being a nativist, Chomsky believed that humans have innate tendency to acquire language.
In this theory, Generative Grammar Chomsky held that but he held that there exist a language Acquisition Device (LAD). LAD hears voice and forms its own rule about the language and thus language acquisition takes place.
In his Transformational Grammar he held that humans are capable to creating sentence which have not heard before before of the understanding of language at surface and semantic level..
Evaluation
Both the theories have been successful in explanation and theirs of language acquisition along with their limitation.
Skinner's theory has been successful in explaining how we acquire language through reinforcement from our parents. eg- When a child ask for food and food is presented he learns the language.
Skinner's theory has been successful in explaining the different dialect of same Language.
But it is very simplified and cannot explain - (i) how individual is able to form sentences never heard before. (ii) Why an error is committed which has not been reinforced.
Chomsky's theory on the other hand is able to explain the complexity of language acquisition. It at explains the drastic pace at which acquisition takes place. It also explains the creativity (poem songs etc) of part in language acquisition.
No one theory can fully explain the process of development of language in human. A combition of both the theories is able to explain the complex process of language acquisition.