Topper Copies

2(a) How far do you agree with the Statement - "Big 5 - factor Theory oversimplifies the complex subject of personality in humans"? Is this simplification good or bad?

Ravi Jain

Big-5 factor theory was developed by McCrae and Costa based on statistical a method of factor analysis.

It is taxonomically and lexically based and as [?] have a universal meaning. This has relevence in complex language such as German and Chinese also.

It states that human personality can be explained based on five traits -

(i) Openness – Degree to which the individual is accepting new ideas, thoughts and situation. Opposites of this is close. (ii) Conscientiousness – ability of individual to handworking, diligent (iii) Extraversion – individuals are outgoing, easy to get along, seek outward stimulation. Opposite of this is introversion. (iv) Agreeableness – ability to get along, easy going. (v) Neuroticism – negative attribute of impulsiveness, agression, anxious.

Thus the complex human personality is simplified into just five traits which have universal acceptance.

Simplification is good

(i) It has huge heuristics value. (ii) Personality inventory has been developed based on this - Neuroticism/ Extraversion Openness - Personality Inventory (NEO-PI). (iii) It is emperically based. (iv) It has huge applied value in management, recruitment, academics. (v) It has universal acceptance.

Simplification is Bad

(i) It has oversimplified complex human personality. (ii) The list is not exhaustive. (iii) It only explains the personality trait and does not explain how it develops. (iv) It is not based on any theory, (v) Inspite of the demerits, the theory has been quite popular due to its huge heuristic and applied value.