The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Affirmative Action is crucial to redressal of historical disadvantages and for fostering equity-based socio-political justice.
Implications for social justice
Positive
1. Broad based definition of "affirmative action" and those deprived 2. Effectuation of "justice - economic" (Preamble) 3. "Without economic democracy, political equality is chimerical" - S Radhakrishnan 4. True multidimensional understanding of depravity requires economic dimension 5. Effecting pro-poor policies to create true "republic" of people 6. Representation in public office aids social mobility 7. Capability approach - securalised access to education - Amartya Sen's capability approach 8. Crucial in the face of rising inequality (Oxfam)
Negative
1. Violation of 50% rule (Indra Sawhney) 2. Lacks data-based determination of economic weakness threshold at ₹8 lakh (SC) 3. Constitutional provisioning only for "social" historic disadvantage (Article 338)
Goal realisation
1. SC approval of EWS reservation given 2. Socio-economic conjunction of justice 3. Aids opportunity seeking for all sections
The amendment postulates India as a true "welfare state" edified on inclusive growth.