How do Skinner & Chomsky differ in their approach to language development? Also, discuss the processes & outcomes of bilingualism & multilingualism in Indian context.
Unknown
The Language development is explained by various psychologists attributing it to differing aspects of innate and environmental domain.
Skinner & Chomsky approach to language development
| Skinner | Chomsky | |---|---| | 1) Behaviourist perspective of language development emphasis on their environmental factors aiding in Learning of Language | 1) Nativist perspective attributes development of language to the innate framework of Universal grammar and language Acquisition Device (Elliott) | | 2) Reinforcements decide the speed and extent of language learn | 2) The innate ability to identify and speak and Language development | | 3) Language learning can happen throughout life. Ex: New language can be learnt without compromising on expertise even after adulthood | 3) Critical period elicits the effective learning of Language after which it is difficult to achieve expertise. Ex: American Sign Language(ASL) Experiment by Devillices & Devillers | | 4) Linguistic and syntactic skills are acquired by learning | 4) Universal Grammar. and the non-bias against learning any language show we are not predisposed to not learning any language | | 5) Forms the basis of language therapy, speech therapies of intellectual / linguistic disabilities. Ex: Autism | 5) Doesn't endorse on any therapy in particular |
Hence, both approaches give great insight into language development often complementary.
Bilingualism & Multilingualism
Processes
1. Code Switching Theory :- the cognitive flexibility of transferring words to different objects (Lambert & Peal) - different words -> objects 2. Socialization : Multilingual parents and migrant population expose children to different languages during their critical period - Mohanty terms multilingualism is a way of life in India 3. Mass media - Job market; Educational institutions -, cross application of languages -> Hinglish (Hindi + English) Thindi (Telugu + Hindi) by teachers; social contexts in clean leaving exposure to multiple languages. - 3-language policy by NEP also adds to the
Outcomes
- cognitive - social cultural + integration ; - emotional. avoiding culture shock ; efficacy in learn & diff lang ;
1. Overcoming mental set: Bialystok & Shapen - through code switching ; mental flexibility improve problem solving skill 2. Framework of learning - leads to discovery of universal grammatical rules of syntax & pragmatics lay foundation for learning more languages - Bilingualism a gateway to Multilingualism 3. Better Academic & Professional Performance - Research points to better Self-regulation (Verbal Mediation Theory) showing higher IQ and EI levels in Bilinguals [Multilingual]
Hence, the 3-language formula needs to be better Implemented to reap the benefits of multilingualism on the cognitive growth of students building upon Skinner's & Chomsky's models