Topper Copies

How do Heuristic & Algorithm differ as problem solving strategies? Illustrate the role of mental set in reasoning with the help of experimental evidence.

Unknown

Humans use various strategies in problem solving. Algorithmic and Heuristic strategies are two most significant approach.

| Algorithmic process | Heuristics | |---|---| | 1) Take a step by step- sequential process to approach different steps of problem => Approval of social schemes systematic process | 1) Take short cuts or thumb rules to elicit decision making using past info and intuitive understanding => Choosing among two different brands | | 2) Often, these are fool proof, data backed and systematic. | 2) Data backing is often absent. => Representation Heuristics ignore the base rate (Tversky) | | 3) Employs meta-cognition in planning and evaluation [Ex] Time taken for each step is laid down by meta-cognitive feed back | 3) Thumb rules like speed of recall; default options decide problem soln- [Ex] Availability Heuristic & Anchoring bias (design choice architecture in consent taking applications) | | 4) Not often prone to errors since it is systematic & data backed | 4) Prone to errors in performance [Ex] no. of road accident related deaths are more than flight accidents, yet people are more afraid of flight accidents | | 5) Slow and time/resource intensive | 5) Ensures cognitive economy. |

Role of Mental Set in Reasoning

1. Mental set refers to the fixation of problem solving to a particular method - a) Ex: Using same set of shots for a different bowler in cricket. - b) Mental set is more plausible when using Heuristics -> since systematic procedures don't fall prey to short cut or indirect solutions

Luchin's problem is a good example:- where participants are asked to figure out a way to make handle. Stand on the wall using matchbox; nail and a thread: - This rigidity of mental set arised from Functional Fixedness Nisbett - Mental set may increase the speed of solving problems but may fail in solving new problems - Associations overlap and learning transfer cause mental set. through functional fixedness.