Topper Copies

5 (a) Examine Gender differences in mental health problems citing research evidences.

T Bhuvanesh Ram

Mental illnesses are defined as behaviours that are dysfunctional, personally distressing, deviant & potentially dangerous. It is experienced differently based on many factors & gender is one of them.

Gender difference in mental health problems

1. Anxiety disorders / mood disorders; Research studies deploying naturalistic observation & case studies show that prevalence of depression is higher in women. 2. There is a higher incidence of histrionic & borderline personality disorder in women, than men. 3. the evidence in substance abuse disorders has been mixed, with no clear gender differences. 4. Similarly, Schizophrenia has no clear difference in incidence rates.

Examination

1. Gender differences are not easily discernible because - a) Women are discouraged from seeking therapy as its 'additional expenditure' - b) Men are stereotyped to be 'strong' & 'have it together' - c) Most of these studies are West-centric & urban-centric with poor cross-cultural validity. - d) Definition of disorders itself is dynamic & change with society. 2. The complex interplay of evolutionary determinants (like higher aggression in men), cultural stereotyps, parenting etc may explain these gender differences. 3. Studies also show that women experience all emotions more intensively than men (except anger) & so are prone to mood disorders.

Though differences exist, greater cross-cultural valid research is needed to study more regarding the reasons of the same.