(b) Expertise can be a barrier to creative problem-solving. Discuss. What are different ways to overcome these?
T Bhuvanesh Ram
Creative problem-solving refers to the generation of original & novel solutions. Expertise for problem solving has generated considerable debate regarding its utility.
Is expertise an obstacle for creativity ?
1. Studies show that experts & novice take different approach to problem solving. 2. Expert rely on experience, vertical thinking, algorithms 3. Novice rely on lateral thinking, street-smartness & heuristics. 4. Experts are more prone to functional-fixedness & mental sets due to past successful experiences. 5. Experts rely less on analogies & largely engage in convergent thinking, whereas creative individuals focus on divergent thinking. 6. Experts focus on quality of solution. Creative Novices prefer fluency & flexibility of solution.
However, expertise of a basic level is necessary. Amabile & Sternberg creativity theories enlist domain knowledge needed as one of its resources for creativity.
Ways to overcome constraints of expertise
1. Techniques like proving that a problem can't be solved can help experts think unconventionally. 2. Heuristics like - Forming subgoals - working backwards - removing unnecessary constraints
can help experts 3. Edward De Bono's 6 hat methodology can be used to promote Lateral thinking. 4. Brainstorming (Osborne) must be undertaken to increase potential solutions. 5. Abstractive thinking & analogies 6. Taking help of an outsider or creative novice to get an alternative cognitive pathway. 7. Deliberation-without-attention (Dijksterhuis) can also help in deploying fast & frugal thinking in experts.
Expertise has both pros & cons, the latter can also be addressed to enhance creativity.