Topper Copies

4 (a) What are the psychological motives behind retarded development of the Indian economy, according to some psychologists? Discuss

T Bhuvanesh Ram

Economic development is an imperative for socio-economic welfare of any society. Despite being the fifth largest economy, poverty is prevalent in India.

Various psychological motives & factors are responsible for this poor economic state of affairs.

1. Need for Achievement: David McClelland proposed that n-Ach levels affect the level of economic development in any society. In his study 'The Achieving Society' of 1961, he proposed that rural areas of Bihar have lower n-Ach than an industrialised city like Kanpur. 2. Dependence motivation :

Development = (Achievement motivation x Extension motivation) - Dependence motivation

Pareek proposed that the high level of dependence in India (of women, elders, SC/ST) on the employed population) also is a reason for retarded development. 3. need for power : This psychosocial motive promote economic inequality, which is prevalent in India, compared to China. 4. Other psychological factors include - a) Poor nutritional status, which impacts cognitive development (Raine et al) - b) Frustration-aggression amidst marginalised societies. - c) Lower socio-economic status leading to poor human capital - - d) Delinquent sub-cultures & substance abuse peer culture among disadvantaged children.

Critique

1. It is important to note that McClelland's theory was modelled on developed economies where resource availability is high. 2. Causation-correlation confusion: Poor socio-economic status is both a cause & consequence of retarded human development & derivatively economic development. 3. It is tough to generalise that n-Ach or entrepreneurial behaviour is poor in India as a whole.

Entrepreneurship Development Programme (EDP) Achievement motivation training (AMT) coupled (reduce relative deprivation) with equitable distribution of resources can help in the advancement of Indian economy.