Topper Copies

What is the difference between compliance and obedience? Discuss with the help of relevant psychological studies.

T Bhuvanesh Ram

Social influence is the impact of imagined or real presence of others on individual behavior. Compliance & Obedience are two types of social influence that determine the impact of group members on a person's conduct.

Compliance -> "public conformity" - Kelman -> "getting others to accede to one's requests"

Obedience -> "following the direction of a person in authority" ->most direct form of social influence.

| Compliance | Obedience | |---|---| | 1. Doesn't involve coercion | 1. Involves coercion. | | 2. Doesn't involve authority figures | 2. Necessity of authority figure to be present | | 3. Example: Agreeing to buy a sauce, based on salesman's persuasion | 3. Ex: Agreeing to buy the sauce because very strict father told so. | | 4. Exhibited via principles of: Ingratiation; commitment; reciprocity; scarcity; pique technique (Santos); Deadline | 4. Uses principles of: exhibiting signs of authority; rejecting dissent. | | 5. A person may not experience distress due to compliance | 5. may experience distress due to compliance |

Research studies

Compliance

1. Robert Cialdini has conducted multiple experiments to demonstrate the effect of principles of flattery, scarcity etc. 2. A study by Santos et al showed that people respond more positively to strange requests than to ordinary ones. Ex: the study involved asking for donation of unusual amount like 37¢ instead of 50¢. Former showed high compliance

Obedience: The classic study by Milgram where participants were made to administer fake shocks (up to 300V) to confederates who apparently fail a memory task, showed effect of obedience. In original version, >67% applied the full 300V shock.

Compliance & obedience can be smartly used in social settings, to get things done.