Topper Copies

Critically examine Herzberg's 2-factor theory of motivation and point out that in what way Herzberg's theory is different from Maslow's theory?

T Bhuvanesh Ram

Theories of work motivation investigate the underlying factors for optimum professional performance. Among content theories, Herzberg & Maslowian theories are highly influential.

Herzberg two factor theory

Summary: 1. Hygiene factors avoid dissatisfaction, whereas motivators are crucial for satisfaction

Fig: Two factor theory

2. The theory lays down that hygiene factors are a basic necessity, beyond which motivators can help in retaining the job 3. For optimal performance, a job role needs both hygiene factors & motivators to be present.

Positives

1. It explains that various extraneous factors like poor relation with superiors can also cause job dissatisfaction 2. Enables the prepotency of hygiene factors before motivators. 3. Gives the importance of higher level motivators as like inherent reward of job 4. Marries internal motivators & external motivators (hygiene) parsimoniously.

Negatives

1. poor empirical evidence - based on interviews & case studies 2. poor cross cultural validity, as for many developing countries, salary is itself a motivator 3. Landy et al show that Herzberg could have derived other conclusion from the findings as well.

Comparison

| Maslow theory | Herzberg theory | |---|---| | 1. Broader range of need including physiological & self-actualisation | 1. Narrow set of need i.e found on job-specific needs like peer-relationship | | 2. Vague idea of self-actualisation | 2. Needs defined concretely. | | 3. Doesn't explain the case of 'starving artist' | 3. More concerned with removal of hygiene factors. | | 4. Broader theory of motivation | 4. Specific to work motivation | | 5. Includes esteem needs | 5. Doesn't include esteem needs. | | 6. Subjectivity in finding need satisfaction. Ex: when belongingness is satisfied | 6. Relatively objective needs are included. Ex: cleanliness, organisational health, cordiality of relationship etc |

Both theories are also similar as they are - hierarchical - deal with higher order needs - face criticism due to subjective nature of needs.

Thus, both the theories are influential in explaining work motivation.