Discuss the debate of heredity v/s environment in acquiring intelligence.
Unknown
Intelligence refers to the ability of an individual to think rationally, act purposefully and deal effectively in their environment. (Wechsler)
Role of heredity in acquiring intelligence
1. Family studies (Heissen etal.) - the more closely two persons are related, the closer their IQ will be. - Eg Identical twins' correlation +0.90 - brother and sister +0.50 - cousins +0.15 2. Identical twins raised apart (Bouchard) - high IQ correlation - even found similar on idiosyncratic functions. 3. Adoption studies - correlation between adopted children and their biological parents increased with age, rather than adopting parents. 4. Contribution of genetic factors increases with age in intelligence (Plomin) around 35% in childhood to 75% in adulthood.
Role of environment in acquiring intelligence
1. Flynn effect – avg. performance on IQ tests has increased by 3 IQ points in the last two decades. - It could not be due to change in genetics but better socio-economic status, better health and education indicators, nutrition etc. have contributed to it 2. studies on environmental appreciation - Steele found that children from sterile and deprived backgrounds when placed in favourable environment showed improved intelligence. 3. studies on environmental deprivation - Misra and Tripathi showed that alcohol, substance abuse and poverty adversely impacts intelligence levels. 4. Ramey and Ramey demonstrated how early intervention in a child's environment to provide unconditional positive regard, positive motivation, healthy life style & education can improve intelligence levels.
Intelligence, is thus, a result of complex interplay between heredity/ genetic factors and environmental factors.