Topper Copies

Critically analyse Guilford's theory of multiple intelligence.

Unknown

Guilford propounded the structure of Intellect model to study intelligence He used factor analysis (a psychometric tool) to establish that there are 180 different types of intellectual abilities that are organized along 3 dimensions.

1. Operations - abilities of an individual - i) Cognition: information processing ability - ii) Memory encoding - iii) Memory retrieval - iv) Divergent production - ability to generate Multiple solutions - v) Convergent production - ability to deduce a single problem to the solution. - vi) Evaluation - ability to judge the correctness or wrongness of information

[a cuboid with edges labelled "6 products", "5 contents" and "6 operations"]

2. Content dimension – it is the nature of information on which intellectual operations are performed. - i) visual ii) Auditory iii) symbolic iv) semantic v) Behavioural. 3. Product dimension – it is the result of intellectual operation on the content. - i) units – single items of knowledge - ii) classes – set of units with common properties. - iii) Relations – Linkages between units - iv) systems – multiple relations forming complex system - v) Transformations – changing made on perceptions / Knowledge - vi) Implications – consequences, inferences etc

Thus according to Guilford, we possess 180 intellectual abilities (6×5×6) and each ability is defined in 3 dimensions

Critical evaluation

Advantages : 1. Extensive use of Factor analysis ∴ comprehensive list of abilities. 2. brought social, emotional, creativity related aspects within ambit of intelligence. 3. Finds applications in Educational setting for diagnostic and remedial purposes. 4. Good heuristic impact.

Limitations : 1. No underlying basis explained for different abilities. PASS theory based on Luria's framework. 2. List of abilities is not extensive 3. Completely ignored the role of 'g' factor 4. Theory appears to be a mere conglomeration of different abilities put together.

Due to these criticisms, Guilford's theory has not found major acceptance in Psychological circles but it helped expand the understanding of intelligence.