Topper Copies

What do you understand by "integrity-based civil disobedience"? Do you think a challenge to personal integrity can be a justifiable cause for responsible disobedience in civil services? Explain.

Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023

Integrity based civil disobedience can be understood as rejecting any law or senior orders on the basis of moral values. eg.) Asking for reconsidering orders to seniors.

Challenge to personal integrity can be a justifiable cause for responsible disobedience

1. It helps in upholding honesty and probity in civil services 2. It helps in avoidance of cognitive dissonance. eg) Manjunath IAS has been transferred 40 times but doesn't deter his fight against corruption. 3. Impartial advice to political class against their orders can help promote accountability towards public.

However, there are certain drawbacks too :- 1. Undermining neutrality and non partisanship of the civil servants. 2. Putting into question a democratic authority by non-elected civil servants against constitution. 3. It might lead to intrusion into other domains. eg) legislature.

eg.) IAS Shah Faisal has commented on Article 370. => against neutrality.

Thus, a balance - Aristotle's golden mean should be put to use in such situations.