Topper Copies

In struggling with misfortune lies the true proof of virtue.

Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023

The book "Sapiens" by Yuval Noah Harari has been a talk of the town nowadays. The early phase of human evolution shown and illustrated in the book portrays the true essence of how misfortunes can present an opportunity to struggle and make our character shine.

When the volcanoes erupted 4 million years ago and photosynthesis slowed down abruptly, the mountain of misfortunes spelled near doom for the apes on trees. Yet, the character of a distinct minority among them shone with the virtue of resilience as they cooperated flexibly and in large numbers, ultimately climbing down from the trees forever and evolving into humans.

Had that distinct minority not shown the heart of a lion in the face of adversity, the planet would have been starkly different. This itself shows the humongous significance of struggling with misfortune but this adage is equally relevant today.

Life is full of uncertainties and we never when we could lose a near and dear one or which day might be our last. However this fear of death or of the inevitable must not come in the path of perpetual progress. As it is said one can evade the reality of misfortunes but not the consequences of that reality, adversity quotient of an individual determines whether he/she would hide their head in sand like an ostrich or face the tide by flying above the clouds like an eagle.

Disasters and mishaps are many a times inevitable. The massive earthquakes of 1956 and then 2001 in Gujarat (Bhuj) fill our heart with grief. Yet they present a case study of how adversity quotient and learning life lessons from such mishaps can show real character of a problem solving attitude. The disaster after 1956 resilient infrastructure constructed by Anjar area not just portrayed the attitude of strategic vision but also muted the impact of the 2001 earthquake.

Not just a problem solving attitude, but such mishaps also help to develop depth in our character and psychological capacity. The analogy of the Biosphere 2 experiment, where the trees provided with all comforts of water and protected from strong winds tended to fall down and lacked the strength in their stem or the depth in the roots. In the natural environment, the windy challenges and search for hard earned water would have shaped their resilience.

Human character is very similar to those trees, as we can safely say that Malala Yousufzai or Kailash Satyarthi would have not been Nobel laureates had they not been faced with their own misfortunes and had they not fought with those tragedies of being hit by a bullet in the head (Miss Yousufzai hit by Taliban's bullet) with fortitude. Such people are the ones who provide meaning and some substance to sayings like "When the going gets tough, the tough get going".

A similar spirit of biting the bullet and moving out of own comfort zone was shown in line with India's PM's saying of "Opportunity in adversity" (aapada me avsar). When COVID came, everyone was caught unprepared and with a serious lack of planning. India didnt even have masks to prevent the community spread. Yet the leadership went all guns blazing and within a few days, established a supply chain which turned India from a mask importer to a mask exporter. A similar feat with our vaccine maitri diplomacy upheld our selfless character and the virtue of vasudhaiva kutumbakam.

Such a selfless attitude by India proves that one may not move a mountain but can cast a stone to create ripples in the water. In fact, water itself has been a point of contention and a misfortune for many just because of their birth in a certain caste. Being born in a dalit family, mostly meant that the individual would become a prisoner of his/her fate and bow down to the ascriptive tyranny. Yet, true knowledge and wisdom of the holy Bhagwad Gita exhorts the individual to not just fight such tragedies of ideas but also create a liveable space for others who are on the same boat. Such a battle by Dr. BR Ambedkar, called the Mahad Satyagraha, not just made public water accessible to his kins, but also shaped the Constitutional morality towards affirmative action.

However, only looking at the humans who struggled against misfortune is like looking at flesh without blood. Surrending to fate is more rampant than the struggle against misfortune. Be it the high suicide rates or the animalistic existence of being a ship stuck at harbour, lack of courage of conviction and the motivation of action is chaining down humanity.

The primary reason here is that such a struggle needs not only the heart of a lion but also a resolve made of steel. Such abilities are possessed by few as Carl Jung had said that us humans are governed by two sovereign masters - pain and pleasure. The pain of action with uncertainty of outcome imprisons people in their shell of despair where they blame everything on God and resign to their destiny.

The lack of completeness of this half baked cake makes us question if such a struggle against misfortune always leads to a virtuous character? The examples of Hitler struggling to revive lost German glory and of Naxals trying to fight against lack of regional development show otherwise. These point at what is called the boomerang effect whereby such a tragedy of commons can fill certain hearts with the vices of hatred and anger. In such a mindless state, they adopt the path of revengeful war without realising that only the dead have seen the end of war.

Such a negative attitude becomes an enemy of the right understanding and fills the soul with the desire for tyranny. Eventual events like the holocaust and the famous photograph of a Jewish woman running away from German kids fills us with remorse thinking how generations get devoid of the virtues of love and compassion.

Thereby we see that it is not easy to show courage in the face of adversity and hence everyone needs to hone their skills for achieving true proof of virtues. Learning from the lives of greats like Gandhi teaches us how the right attitude is necessary to uphold values even in face of all tyranny. We can learn from the Chauri Chaura incident how upholding integrity in face of unfortenate violence against policemen eventually enhanced the credibility and mass following of Gandhi.

Development of leadership skills too is necessary for such a gift of credibility. The emotional intelligence developed via introspection and voice of conscience helps to see the larger picture and work for the common good in face of tragedy just like SDM of Bahraich who, seeing inadvertent possibility of dams, himself started lifting sand bags to motivate those around him to face adversity collectively, and avoid flooding.

In the end, such an ability of collective action as highlighted in "Sapiens" will help take the next giant leap for humanity and unveil our inner strength and moral character and make all such misfortunes the canvas upon which our virtues would be painted in illuminating and brilliant hues.