What are the various problems of measuring intelligence by means of intelligence tests? Give suitable illustrations.
Unknown
Intelligence refers to one's ability to think rationally, act purposefully and deal effectively with their environment. (Wechsler)
Intelligence is measured by intelligence tests and the result is intelligence quotient (IQ). 1st intelligence test was prepared by Binet-Simon and since then it has undergone evolution due to various problems.
Problems
1. Definition & understanding - lack of clarity and consensus regarding what intelligence is & its components. - Eg different psychometric theories like Gardner, Guilford etc and different process theories like PASS model, Sternberg's triarchic theory etc. All conceptualise intelligence differently. 2. Culture bias - sampling, norms and Test contents are culture sensitive ∴ intelligence tests often lack cross-cultural validity. - WAIS has been evolved many times to overcome such issues. - It was found that African-Americans often scored lower than original Americans, it was because of culture bias in Tests. 3. Performance on Test - elevated score due to training - non-cognitive factors such as emotional state, motivation, environmental factors in which test is taken may also produce incorrect results. 4. Faking and guessing on intelligence tests produces incorrect results. 5. Result interpretation - raw test scores are extrapolated using Inferential statistics ∴ the results produced are prone to errors. - interpretation of test results is also subject to Individual's biases
Thus, it is often said that intelligence is what intelligence test measures because it doesnot give the holistic understanding of the individual's actual cognitive capacity. Despite these issues constant improvements are made such as culture fair tests, non-verbal tests for illiterate, adaptations of western tests like Jodhpur intelligence test battery of WAIS.