1 (b) Compare and contrast Psychoanalytical concept with Behaviorist Reinterpretation.
Manasvi Sharma
Both Psychoanalytical concept and Behaviorist Reinterpretation were the two dominant forces of early psychology. Behaviorist concept was propounded as a reaction to psychoanalytical concept.
| PSYCHOANALYTICAL CONCEPT | BEHAVIORIST REINTERPRETATION | |---|---| | 1. First propounded by Sigmund freud. | 1. First propounded by Watson and later expanded by Pavlov and BF Skinner | | 2. Focussed on internal causes of human behavior and disorders | 2. Specific focus on overt and measurable behavior | | 3. Childhood traumatic experiences, anxiety, repressed Memories are the major internal source of our behavior | 3. Stressed on Stimulus – Response association i.e. Manipulable determinants of our behavior lie in envt. | | 4. This theory is based on the principle of Psychic determinism | 4. Environmental determinism became Its cornerstone. | | 5. This theory was developed on Case studies of Freud's patients ∴ have little experimental basis of explanation | 5. Behaviorist theory was specifically developed to make Psychology as a scientific and experimental Subject. |
Thus, although both views have varying and opposite view of the subject and interpretation of Psychology they have advanced Psychological understanding of human behavior: 1. Psychodynamic Therapy based on reinterpretation of Freudian principle. 2. Behavior Therapy on behaviorist principle. 3. Use of Behaviorist principles in advancing application in Education, Guidance etc. 4. Advancing the scope of Psychology overall.