Compare and contrast Trait theories & Psychoanalytical theory with respect to the concept of Personality.
Vikas Yadav, AIR 776, 2024
Gordon allport defined personality as internal organization of those Psychophysical systems which help us predict thoughts & behavior.
Traits theory and Psychoanalytical theory differ in following ways ÷
1. The structure of PERSONALITY :
Trait theories held traits to be the structure of personality. for.eg Cattell talks about 16 Personality factors, Big - Five about 5.
Psychoanalytical theory held that id , ego & super ego form the structure of personality.
[a drawn figure of the structure of personality as an iceberg-like oval divided into conscious, preconscious and unconscious levels, with ego at the top, superego on the left and id below] fig Structure of Personality
Other differences:
| Trait | Psychoanalytic | |---|---| | 2. The dynamics of personality includes how these traits interact to give rise to behavior. | 2. The dynamics of personality includes how psychic energy is distributed among id, ego, & super ego. | | 3. The development of personality is not discussed by Trait Theories | 3. The psychosexual stages ( Anal, oral, phallic, latency & Genital ) point to the development of personality | | 4. No focus on Unconscious process | 4. High focus on Unconscious process | | 5. Criticized from situationist point of view (Walter Mischel) | 5. Criticized because of lack of falsifiability |
In addition, psycho analytic theory talks about therapies to change the personality while trait theories provide no such interventions.
Despite, criticisms, both theories helped in development of the field of personality.