Case study: an SDM, an inter-caste couple and a hostile village
Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025
The Supreme Court in "Hadiya case" has upheld the right of an adult to marry person of their choice - as implicit in Right to liberty under Art 21. The present case highlights conflict between individual liberty and societal dogmas.
(a) stakeholders and associated issues
| Stakeholder | Issues | |---|---| | 1. the couple | violation of right to marry person of choice<br>against liberalism and individualism (Rousseau)<br>safety of life and dignity (Art. 14, 19 to move about freely) | | 2. Villagers | negative attitude towards inter-caste marriages<br>regressive approach towards youth choices [Swami Vivekananda's ethics of progression violated]<br>caste conflicts - against social justice and Plato's Kallipolis (a just city) | | 3. Boy's Family | victimization faced (against humanism of Raja Ram Roy)<br>threat to life (violates Art 21) | | 4. SDM(Mr) | law and order challenges (eg) flaring up tensions lead to violence as seen in Manipur<br>moral compass requires intervention<br>Compassion V/s Objectivity: to protect them -> Compassion; leave the trouble of involvement -> Objectivity |
(b) Options available
(I) Comply with couple's request for intervention - merits - uphold moral bureaucracy (of Confucius) - supererogation (going beyond call of duty & virtue) - demerits - backlash from villagers and personal consequences
(II) Refuse to intervene - merits - maintain objectivity (ethical egoism) - no risk of losing villagers confidence - demerits - law and order situation (chaos, conflict) - responsibility and Categorical imperative violated
(III) Intervention as per call of duty and protect couple - merits - upholding Aristotelian justice courage - respect for couple's right to life - demerits - risk of slippery slope (involvement in caste conflicts)
Course of action
By adopting the Madhyam Marg (as Buddha propounded), I have effected a Nishkam karma