Topper Copies

Case study: a mobile company sourcing tin from mines that use child labour, with you as its Head of Ethics

Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025

" The future of the world is either green or not at all" — Bobby Brown

'green' here highlights sustainable living - which counters challenge of environmental degradation, unethical corporate supply chains, hazardous working conditions etc.

(a) Ethical issues in the case

1. Eco-centrism v/s anthropocentrism - mining tin at the cost of landslides damaging pristine environment 2. Means v/s ends - using labourers as mere means of profit [ violating the 2nd categorical Imperative of Kant] 3. violation of corporate citizenship duties (ef) no regard to laws like child Labour Prohibition Act 2016. 4. Profitability at the cost of sustainability i.e. selling mobiles without ethicality of supply chains

(b) Consumers of the Company are required to take into account child labour and unsafe mining operation in line with Project Earth, Mission LiFE. - sustainable living (ef) avoiding fruits of unfair labour practices - mindful consumption in line with Socratic "Unexamined life is not worth living" - constitutional duties (eg) under Art 51A - Inner conscience

(c) My suggested course of action

1. filter out mines using child labour (eg) by using Walmart -style real-time AI monitoring 2. frame a company policy on "Sustainable supply Chains" and notify it to existing stakeholders [suppliers, customers] and publish on website 3. Satiating shareholders by persuasion: - Pavlovian conditioning (eg) giving example of sustainable market index like ESG or Greenex in India - instrumental conditioning (of) apprising of moral hazards associated with child labour 4. Appeal to customers: - to not reject company's products till company enquires and filters out its supply chains - highlight complexity of the identification process while being committed to compassionate capitalism.

Thus, by acting as a truly "Head of Ethics", I would have upheld "work is worship" and values of trusteeship by Gandhiji.