Topper Copies

Case study: an NRI tycoon's lavish wedding in an ecologically fragile hill district

Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025

Opulence of weddings and their resultant hype are causes of concern - not just from wastefulness of productive investment but also sustainability of the ceremonies. "There is enough for everybody's need, but not for anyone's greed" - Gandhi ji

(a) Stakeholders and their interests

| Stakeholder | Interests | |---|---| | 1. Local residents | pristineness of local environment be maintained<br>prosperity of district (eg) employment opportunities, tourism potential brought by prospective wedding | | 2. Local MLA | development in the hill district (Art. 38 of Constitution)<br>respect for environment be ensured (Art 48 A)<br>political mileage from hosting business tycoon's wedding | | 3. Prominent citizen | need for local investment opportunities (ethical egoism)<br>genuine desire for local development (public morality) | | 4. Om (me) | eco-centrism v/s anthropocentrism (to safeguard environment from damage or continue "pay and pollute")<br>constitutional morality (Art 48A, Art 51(A)(g)) | | 5. Tycoon (NRI) | extravagance (Aristotleaian vice)<br>private interest over public interest<br>privileged shallow ecologism (offer to pay for damage) |

(b) Options available

(I) allow the wedding - Merits: - upholding commitment to citizen welfare - developmental goals achieved - Demerits - loss of integrity (cognitive dissonance) - violation of environment ethics [Bhumih Mata of vedas]

(II) Prohibit the wedding - Merits: - adherence to Gandhi's Need based usage - example of sustainable living - Demerits - loss of prospective business (in tourism and otherwise) - mutual mistrust with local MLA and prominent residents

(III) Allow with conditions - Merits: - followed "Stop & Go determinism" (Griffith Taylor) - achieved citizen satisfaction and collegiality with residents - Demerits: in possible destruction of environment - might lose wedding altogether.

Course of action

Reasons: - Reacralization of environment needed (eg) World Risks Report pointed loss of biodiversity - pristineness of hill preserved and eco-tourism promoted (eg in line with Dekho Apna Desh) - Objectivity balanced with compassion for residents - Aristotle's Golden Mean

Thus, I will have ensured temperance in approaching the issue